- Put a tracked phone number on each campaign so every call from the card is counted.
- Add a QR code that opens a page only the card links to, so every scan is counted.
- Match addresses: compare your booked jobs to the addresses you mailed. That catches people who call your main number.
- Count jobs that happen after the drop date, inside a set window you decide ahead of time.
- Return = (revenue from matched jobs − campaign cost) ÷ campaign cost.
Why most mail results are a guess
A homeowner gets your card, puts it on the fridge, and three weeks later looks you up on Google and calls your main line. Your office logs it as a Google lead. The mail did the work and got no credit. That's why tracking needs more than one method.
Four ways to track
| Method | How it works | What it misses |
|---|---|---|
| Tracked phone number | A separate number on the card forwards to your office and logs every call | People who call your main number |
| QR code | Opens a page only the card links to, so every scan is counted | People who type your website or call |
| Offer code | “Mention code FALL89” | Customers or staff who forget the code |
| Address match | Compare booked jobs to the list of homes that got the card | Jobs booked under a different address |
Address matching: the method that catches the most
Address matching works only with addressed mail, because you need the list of homes you mailed. Export your booked jobs from your field service software (ServiceTitan, Housecall Pro, Jobber or QuickBooks all export jobs or invoices with service addresses), then match them to the mailed list.
- Clean both lists first. "123 Oak St" and "123 Oak Street Apt 1" need to match. USPS-standard address formatting helps.
- Only count jobs after the drop. A job booked before the card arrived didn't come from it.
- Set the window ahead of time, for example 90 days after the drop, and stick to it.
- Exclude existing customers if you want to measure new customers only.
The ROI math
Matched revenue = sum of invoices from matched addresses, inside the window
Return = (matched revenue − campaign cost) ÷ campaign cost
Cost per booked job = campaign cost ÷ matched jobs
For a stricter number, use gross margin instead of revenue. A $9,000 install at 40% margin is $3,600 of real return.
Holdout groups
Some matched homes would have called you anyway. To measure that, hold back a random slice of the list, say 10%, and don't mail it. If the mailed homes book at a clearly higher rate than the held-back homes, the difference is what the mail earned.
USPS Informed Delivery
USPS Informed Delivery emails subscribers a preview of the mail arriving that day. Mailers can add an interactive campaign: a ride-along image and a link shown under the scanned image of the piece. USPS says this works on letter-size pieces scanned on its automation equipment, regardless of mail class. Flats need a separate representative image because USPS doesn't image flats. USPS currently offers these campaigns at no extra cost.
Clicks on that link are one more thing you can count.
Common tracking mistakes
- Using your main number on the card, so mail calls blend in with everything else.
- Counting every call as a job. Track booked jobs and revenue, not just calls.
- Changing the offer, the list and the design all at once, so you can't tell what worked.
- Judging after one drop. Give a campaign enough drops and time to show a pattern.
Questions
How do I know if my direct mail worked?
Use a tracked phone number and a QR code on every card, then match your booked jobs to the addresses you mailed. Count only jobs booked after the drop, inside a window you set ahead of time.
What is a good ROI for direct mail?
It depends on your job values and margins. ANA's 2021 report found letter-size envelopes returned 112% and postcards to a company's own customers 92%. Your own tracked results are the benchmark that matters.
Can I track EDDM mail by address?
Not by exact address. EDDM isn't addressed to specific homes, so you can only match jobs by route or ZIP Code. Tracked numbers and QR codes still work.
What is Informed Delivery?
A free USPS service that emails subscribers previews of their incoming mail. Mailers can add a clickable image and link to letter-size pieces processed on USPS automation equipment.